Asia Solidarity Economy Forum 2012 at Manado, Indonesia

The Asian Solidarity Economy Forum 2012 took place from Mon, 01st to Wed, 03rd October at International Business Administration (IBA), Sam Ratulangi University, Manado, Northern Sulawesi, Indonesia.  Hundreds of people from 17 countries (including Canada and 5 European countries) joined this event to share and learn different experiences that have been happening in different parts of this continent.

The day 1 (Mon, 01st October) began with the opening ceremony with a message from Dr. Sinyo Harry Sarundajang, Governor of North Sulawesi. After four Indonesian researchers commented about their visit to Germany thanks to the invitation from Konrad Adenauer Stiftung to learn how the social market economy is working there, Drs. Bambang Ismawan of Bina Swadaya (Indonesia) presented his perspective on solidarity economy. He mentioned the definition on solidarity economy given by Dr. Benjamin Quiñones Jr. (ASEC’s chairman, to be referred to later) as “economy developed by social enterprise”, showed the 3P (People, Planet and Profit) by Dr. Quiñones and underscored that 99.2% of businesses in Indonesia are small or micro enterprises. He also located the solidarity economy for those “economically active but poor,” excluding who are too old or too young and who are the poorest or feasible as conventional small businesses. After accentuating the importance of microcredit on enabling microenterprises’ existence, he explained that the best form of community institutions is self-reliance with “active membership”, “elected leaders”, “Economic + (social & educational)” activities and “democratically participative.” He said that such institutions are “vehicle for mutual learning and teaching, problem identification, decision-making, resource mobilization and communication with 3rd parties” and pointed out their features as “income generating orientation”, “open mindness” and “democratic”.

Then followed Dr. Benjamin Quiñones, Chairman of Asian Solidarity Economy Council (ASEC) from the Philippines who added further information on his definition of Social and Solidarity Economy (SSE). After defining it as something out of the public and private sector, he underscored “people’s participation in ownership & management of resources” and “profit sharing” as co-owners. He identified “solidarity”, “interdependence” and “people-to-people connectivity” as “edifying values” and showed the framework for evaluating SSE from the viewpoint of governance, ethical values, provided social development services, ecological conservation measures and sustainability. Prof. Dato Mohammad Yusof Kasim from University Utara, Malaysia underscored the importance of coops, Prof. Dr. Denison Jayasooria from University Kebangsaan, Malaysia explained that coops and microcredit are one of the key points on the civil society, along with CSR for sustainable development.

In the afternoon five workshops took place (Economic Security, Socially Responsible Governance, Enhanced Social Wellbeing, Healthy Climate and Environment and Edifying Value). Then another plenary took place and Prof. Dr. Paulus Kindangen from Sam Ratulangi University told that the competition by the capitalism has excluded many people, underscored the importance to empower that impoverished people and defined solidarity economy as “way out from the unfairness economic practice of capitalism” while trying not to abolish capitalism but to coexist with it. He mentioned the Article 33 of the Indonesian Constitution to tell that coops’ role is determined as “very important institution in creating or establishing economic democracy in Indonesia”, presented the word “gotong-royong” or “mapalus” as community mutual help, criticized the political intervention as “among the reasons of the cooperative failure”. Ir. Suhaedi from Bank of Indonesia talked about the financial inclusion as one of the biggest challenges of the Indonesian economy and Ms. Vivi George shared her experience of microcredit for women’s productive activities.

The day 2 (Tue, 02nd Oct) started with the presentation by Reiko Inoue, PARCIC Japan, about the hard task of community rebuilding in those coastline regions severely damaged by the tsunami in March 2011 which killed almost 20,000 people. She underlined social capital, market and management skill as most needed factors to develop solidarity economy. Then followed Prof. Wim Poli, professor at Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia told the need to go beyond the sympathy on building solidarity economy. Then Mr. Jay Lacsamana from the Foundation for a Sustainable Society (the Philippines) explained about this foundation, created as a result from the debt-for-development swap, arranged between the governments of the Philippines and the Switzerland, and told its commitment to the creation of social enterprises and to the local economy development. Then as a case study Mr. Ari Primatoro shared his experience to stimulate the farming in Punur Watershed, Central Java, explaining three achievements (self-help groups promotion, business development services, and market linkage). Mr. Gian Mansa shared his experience of bamboo handicrafts. And Ms. Jeanne Marie O. Bernardo from On Eagle’s Wings Foundation (the Philippines) narrated how she applied the five dimensions of social solidarity economy, namely “social mission-oriented or socially responsible governance”, “edifying value”, “social development services”, “ecological conservation” and “sustainability” onto the Free Range Chicken Supply Chain.

Then another session on finance started. Magnus Young from Impact Investment Exchange Asia (Singapore) explained the social investment opportunities in Asia, followed by this blogger (Miguel Yasuyuki Hirota, expert on social and complementary currencies)’s presentation on social and complementary currencies. Then three case studies were given: Bank Negara Indonesia and PNPM in Bahasa Indonesia (Indonesian language), and the rice and onion supply chain APPEND, which improved farmers’ access to loans in better conditions. In the afternoon the ASEF market was held and different businesses, such as bioethanol, houses, handicrafts and tourism services, were shown, and two more cases were shown, namely an organic rice farming in North Sulawesi presented by Ir. Rachmat Mokodongan and an IT centre at Manado called Manadokota by Piet Hein Pusung, in both of which the importance of mapalus was highlighted. Last but not least, Hasan Tjandra from Sigma Global gave a short overview on the hardship in getting credits from the businessman’s viewpoint.

The last day (Wed, 03rd) began with three presentations on the concepts of solidarity economy: Herman Karamoy and Jullie J. Sondakh from the Sam Ratulangi university showed the definition of social enterprises as “one of the nonprofit organizations” and “a branch of non-profit-organization which mainly deliver goods and services mostly through charity funding and voluntarism” (Kam, 2010) and “the organization that apply business methods and practices in providing and improving benefit or value to the society”, locating them between charities and traditional businesses and underlining the importance of social enterprises’ accountability. Yvon Poirier from CCEDNET explained different, although similar, concepts in relation to solidarity economy, such as social economy, social enterprises and third sector, telling that such a diversity in so many parts of the world is a strength while putting such efforts together is a huge challenge. Shomi Kim from British Council in Korea shared the Global Changemaker, a project to involve the youth to the social change. Then professors at IBA shared their teaching experiences and another community training centre ILMU.

And in the final plenary four presentations were given: Benito Lopulalan and Dewi Hutabarat from AKSI-UI Foundation (Indonesia) presented some cases in which Indonesians are already collaborating with Malaysians or Timorese. Olivier Endelin and Florence Valle from Ekovivo (France) showed their project to help social enterprises get access to microcredits by increasing their visibility on the web. Ricarte B. Abejuela and Monique Sengkey pointed out the important fact that the agreement valid for the border islands between Indonesia and the Philippines is rather a hurdle than an incentive to stimulate the solidarity economy in this region as it limits international trades between these two countries. And finally Ibana The from IBA showed their website as a portal site to sell goods made by solidarity economy players in Asia. And on the closing ceremony some IBA students were rewarded for their excellent social enterprise projects.

As this forum was hosted by a business school, it has its own advantages and disadvantages. As advantage I should underline their expertise in business management, marketing and other related skills. And honestly speaking, I was highly impressed by IBA students’ high English proficiency, something quite uncommon in Indonesia.

But at the same time this forum showed some challenges for the future of solidarity economy in Asia, especially in the host country Indonesia: first of all, this forum was rather centred on social enterprises while not enough attention was paid to cooperativism, self-management and these businesses’ relationship with social movements. From my viewpoint, quite influenced by Latin American experiences, the middle class’ role in the solidarity economy, especially in terms of poverty reduction, would be rather to help the poor set up and manage their own coops than set up social enterprises, but it is also important that Asia has complete different historic precedents and, given the fact that many social enterprises have evolved from what used to be charity projects, it’s necessary to respect all the achievements Asians have done so far.

Another point is the limited use of Bahasa Indonesia (Indonesian language) in the conference, which should have kept a huge number of ordinary Indonesians away from this precious event. As solidarity economy is for ordinary people, it’s essential that it should be given in a way ordinary people can understand, and it would be helpful if simultaneous interpretation between English and Bahasa were available.


21 responses to “Asia Solidarity Economy Forum 2012 at Manado, Indonesia

  1. Предоставим Вам возможность, заранее забронировать место в самолете, на котором Вы бы хотели лететь. Закажем для Вас специальную еду; при перелете с грудным ребенком, попросим специальную люльку, отправим запрос на размещение коляски в салоне самолета. Поможем Вам комфортно перевезти Вашего домашнего питомца и многое другое. Другими словами, мы постараемся сделать так, чтобы эта и все последующие поездки, доставили Вам удовольствие. авиабилеты в израиль россия

  2. Проект компании «Юго-Стар». Мы решились создать ресурс, который будет включать в себя все необходимые услуги для вашего путешествия, в целях экономии вашего времени. авиабилеты москва запорожье

  3. Компания «Юго-Стар» предлагает Вам отдых в Чехии, Финляндии, Черногории, Сербии, Словакии, Израиле и других странах. Бронирование отелей и билетов, лечение на курортах, пляжный и горнолыжный отдых. отдых в теплицe из москвы

  4. Американские грузовики. Полуприцепы из Европы ООО “ТК Транссервис”. У нас в продаже: тягачи КАМАЗ, МАЗ, MAN, DAF, американские грузовики, полуприцепы из Европы Wielton, Krone, ТОНАР, полуприцепы цистерны, широкий выбор спецтехники! полуприцеп тонар

  5. Cмотреть фильмы онлайн бесплатно хорошего качества. смотреть хорошего качества онлайн Смотрите фильмы онлайн.Онлайн фильмы бесплатно и кино хорошего качества на нашем портале.

  6. Разобрать, собрать, упаковать мебель и предметы интерьера, перевезти пианино, антикварный шкаф, неподъемный сейф, банкомат, торговое и холодильное оборудование, осуществить такелажные услуги, загрузить, разгрузить машину или контейнер – это услуги грузчиков! Офисный переезд Донецк

  7. Моды для minecraft, майнкрафт рецепты и текстуры. Дорогой гость, на нашем сайте ты сможешь скачать бесплатно и без регистрации моды для minecraft, майнкрафт рецепты, текстуры. мониторинг серверов minecraft 1.4.5

  8. новая вентиляция помещений в Петербурге. современные системы кондиционирования и вентиляции. вентиляция коттеджей, кафе и складов. продажа и срочный монтаж вентиляции по умеренной цене. Вентиляция помещений

  9. Exclusive Private Investors Club. Retirement Club

  10. стильная одежда для девушек. как удалить пятна с одежды

  11. What a great girl Lexi. Subscribed to her channel. Loved your tWitch interview . Saw you last night at Trevors Project talking with Katy Perry. Nice job. And good job for standing upr for no Bullying!!! Check her our guys

  12. Завод лабораторной мебели МеталлДизайн – производство лабораторной мебели и лабораторного оборудования. школьная лаборатория

  13. Всем хай! Захотел посоветоваться, решил сделать приятное родным, сам нахожусь в другом городе. Надумал сделать сюрприз остановился на доставка цветов на дом, может еще какие варианты подарка есть посоветуйте пожалуйста. Заранее благодарен.

  14. Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an really long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all
    that over again. Regardless, just wanted to say superb

  15. В связи с принятием закона в России по контенту “18+” социальная сеть «В контакте» запустили новую соцсеть, отличительной особенностью которой будет размещение анкет интимного характера и отсутствием модерации в целях знакомств и общения на интимные темы.
    Что появилось:
    – возможность загрузки интимных фото и видео
    – отсутствие модерации
    – возможность найти партнера для сeкса
    – более полная контактная информация (телефон, интимные увлечения и проч.)

    Что осталось:
    – голубой фон Вконтакте
    – как и прежде привязка аккаунтов к номеру мобильного телефона
    – подарки, значки
    Со слов основателя соцсети, у новой соцсети большое будущее,
    т.к. люди всегда будут искать партнеров для секса на 1-2 раза, а новая соцсеть им поможет в этом.

    [url=]Вот ссылка на соц сеть[/url]


  16. Hiya! Quick question that’s completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My web site looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone. I’m
    trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to correct
    this issue. If you have any suggestions, please
    share. Thanks!

  17. I’m impressed, I must say. Seldom do I come across a blog that’s equally educative and interesting,
    and without a doubt, you’ve hit the nail on the head. The problem is something not enough men and women are speaking intelligently about. I’m very
    happy that I stumbled across this during my hunt for something
    concerning this.

  18. Thank you for sharing your info. I truly appreciate your efforts and I am
    waiting for your further write ups thank you once again.

  19. Всемпривет! Нашёл новый магазин, где продают теплицы, сейчас у них идёт акция, бесплатная доставка по области и бесплатное хранение теплицы на их складе до сезона, и ещё скидка 50% на установку.
    буду покупить у них, т.к. хочу крепкую теплицу, а там есть выбор: 20мм, 25мм и 30мм профиль. Если кому интересно описание и фото теплиц можно посмотреть на их сайте:
    Да, теплицы покрываются поликарбонатом, он тоже входит в стоимость! Вся эта конструкия теплицы крепится на брус для долговечности и чтобы надёжно стояла на огороде =)

  20. anutka_tkach_RodyGroutty

    Все по форексу, финансам и инвестициям

    Гармоничный портфель

  21. искал в гугле продажа телефонов через интернет магазин, нашел ваш блог Asia Solidarity Economy Forum 2012 at Manado, Indonesia | Towards …, спасибо!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s